Goal
Hand the existing independent CounterProof behavior receipt back to the maintainers of:
The technical evidence is already complete.
Evidence
Exact candidates:
- BASE:
41868632dcaba1ad9b6402d114b169564c08d121
- HEAD:
f71185995aee043e2e9acfd31028501f23992aea
Exact submitted test:
scanpipe.tests.test_commands.ScanPipeManagementCommandTest.test_scanpipe_management_command_run_without_input_location
Observed:
HEAD → PASS
BASE + exact submitted HEAD test → FAIL
django.core.management.base.CommandError:
Error: the following arguments are required: input_location
Trusted run:
https://github.com/hippoley/CounterProof/actions/runs/36373412716
Reviewer-facing handoff:
https://github.com/hippoley/CounterProof/blob/main/reality/scancode-2207/MAINTAINER_HANDOFF.md
Machine receipt:
https://github.com/hippoley/CounterProof/blob/main/examples/claim_matrix/receipts/scancode-2207-behavior.json
Outbound attempt
On 2026-10-07, CounterProof attempted to post the maintainer-facing summary directly to ScanCode.io #2207 through the connected GitHub integration.
Result:
403 Resource not accessible by integration
This is a connector permission boundary, not maintainer feedback and not a negative adoption signal.
Ready-to-post comment
For reviewer context, I independently replayed the exact submitted regression test against the exact PR candidates in ScanCode.io's PostgreSQL/Django test shape.
- HEAD
f71185995aee043e2e9acfd31028501f23992aea: PASS
- BASE
41868632dcaba1ad9b6402d114b169564c08d121 with the same submitted test transplanted unchanged: FAIL
- BASE failure:
django.core.management.base.CommandError: Error: the following arguments are required: input_location
Exact test:
scanpipe.tests.test_commands.ScanPipeManagementCommandTest.test_scanpipe_management_command_run_without_input_location
So this does witness the specific before/after behavior claim: the submitted test distinguishes HEAD from BASE because BASE still requires input_location. It does not say anything about unrelated compatibility or whether the PR should merge.
Compact handoff + machine receipt:
https://github.com/hippoley/CounterProof/blob/main/reality/scancode-2207/MAINTAINER_HANDOFF.md
Trusted run:
https://github.com/hippoley/CounterProof/actions/runs/36373412716
Completion condition
Close this issue only when one of these is true:
- the comment is successfully posted upstream, or
- an equivalent maintainer-facing evidence handoff is delivered through another permitted path.
Do not count this issue itself as adoption.
Goal
Hand the existing independent CounterProof behavior receipt back to the maintainers of:
The technical evidence is already complete.
Evidence
Exact candidates:
41868632dcaba1ad9b6402d114b169564c08d121f71185995aee043e2e9acfd31028501f23992aeaExact submitted test:
Observed:
Trusted run:
https://github.com/hippoley/CounterProof/actions/runs/36373412716
Reviewer-facing handoff:
https://github.com/hippoley/CounterProof/blob/main/reality/scancode-2207/MAINTAINER_HANDOFF.md
Machine receipt:
https://github.com/hippoley/CounterProof/blob/main/examples/claim_matrix/receipts/scancode-2207-behavior.json
Outbound attempt
On 2026-10-07, CounterProof attempted to post the maintainer-facing summary directly to ScanCode.io #2207 through the connected GitHub integration.
Result:
This is a connector permission boundary, not maintainer feedback and not a negative adoption signal.
Ready-to-post comment
For reviewer context, I independently replayed the exact submitted regression test against the exact PR candidates in ScanCode.io's PostgreSQL/Django test shape.
f71185995aee043e2e9acfd31028501f23992aea: PASS41868632dcaba1ad9b6402d114b169564c08d121with the same submitted test transplanted unchanged: FAILdjango.core.management.base.CommandError: Error: the following arguments are required: input_locationExact test:
So this does witness the specific before/after behavior claim: the submitted test distinguishes HEAD from BASE because BASE still requires
input_location. It does not say anything about unrelated compatibility or whether the PR should merge.Compact handoff + machine receipt:
https://github.com/hippoley/CounterProof/blob/main/reality/scancode-2207/MAINTAINER_HANDOFF.md
Trusted run:
https://github.com/hippoley/CounterProof/actions/runs/36373412716
Completion condition
Close this issue only when one of these is true:
Do not count this issue itself as adoption.